Negotiating Your Commerce Cloud Deal: Tips for Retailers on Revenue Share and Contracts

Negotiating Your Commerce Cloud Deal

Introduction – Why Negotiation Is Essential

Salesforce Commerce Cloud (formerly Demandware) uses a revenue-share pricing model, meaning it takes a percentage of your online sales. For retailers with tight margins, this model can eat into profits as you grow.

Left unchecked, fees will scale right alongside your revenue, potentially reaching millions for high-GMV (Gross Merchandise Value) businesses. Negotiation isn’t just helpful – it’s essential.

By proactively negotiating your Commerce Cloud agreement, you can rein in costs, prevent surprises, and ensure the platform’s terms align with your business needs.

In short, a savvy negotiation can be the difference between sustainable online growth and a “success tax” that erodes your bottom line.

For a complete overview, read our Salesforce Commerce Cloud Pricing & Negotiation Guide.

Leverage Projected GMV Growth

One of your strongest negotiation levers is your future sales growth.

Salesforce’s pricing is based on GMV, so use your projected growth to your advantage:

• Tiered Revenue Share: Push for a deal where the percentage fee drops as your sales hit milestones. For example, you might start at a 2% fee, but once your annual online sales exceed $100 million, the fee drops to 1.8%. Lock in these milestone-based discounts from the outset instead of a flat one-size-fits-all rate. This way, as your business scales, your fees become proportionally smaller.
• Don’t Overcommit: While it’s tempting to agree to ambitious sales forecasts to get a lower percentage, be realistic. Salesforce will hold you to any committed GMV – if you guarantee $100M in sales for a discount but only hit $80M, you could still pay as if you made $100M. Negotiate for flexibility. It’s better to start with conservative forecasts and include provisions to adjust fees if actuals differ greatly. For instance, ask for mid-term review clauses or “re-opener” terms if your growth is far above or below projections.

By leveraging projected GMV growth in negotiations, you make the case that both parties win: you get cost relief at scale, and Salesforce gains a long-term high-volume client. The key is to bake those benefits into the contract now, rather than hoping for leniency later.

Benchmark Against Competitors

Even if you’re set on Salesforce Commerce Cloud, you should arm yourself with competitor pricing to strengthen your negotiating position.

Salesforce’s revenue-share percentage can be significantly higher than the effective costs of other platforms:

• Compare % Fees: Research what other enterprise eCommerce platforms would cost for your business. For example, Shopify Plus typically charges a much smaller percentage of sales (plus a license fee), and platforms like BigCommerce use fixed subscription tiers rather than a pure revenue cut. If Salesforce is asking for 2% of GMV, note that alternative solutions might equate to only ~0.25–0.5% or a flat fee in comparison. Use those numbers to make Salesforce justify its premium.
• Leverage Intent to Switch: You don’t have to actually switch platforms to benefit from competitive quotes. Simply demonstrating that you know your options puts pressure on Salesforce. Mention that you’ve evaluated Shopify Plus, Adobe/Magento, BigCommerce, etc., and found their costs more predictable or lower at scale. This gives Salesforce a reason to sharpen its pencil and come closer to market rates rather than risk losing the deal. Remember, Salesforce knows migrating platforms is costly for you – but they also know losing a customer (or prospect) to a competitor hurts them. Use that tension to your advantage.
• Push for Price Alignment: When confronted with competitive benchmarks, Salesforce may counter with the platform’s superior features or ecosystem. Acknowledge the strengths, but stay focused on cost. Make it clear that while you value Salesforce’s capabilities, the pricing must be aligned with the value and competitive with the market. Often, Salesforce can be flexible on the percentage or can throw in more for the price when they sense a risk of losing you.

In summary, do your homework on competitor pricing.

Even a simple comparison (e.g., “Platform X would cost us roughly $300k/year versus Salesforce’s $1M at our projected sales”) can be a powerful negotiation card. It shifts the conversation from “take it or leave it” to “meet us somewhere reasonable or we walk.”

Plan for the future, Exit Strategy: What to Negotiate if You Might Leave Commerce Cloud in the Future.

Clarify Total Cost of Ownership

Negotiating a Commerce Cloud deal isn’t just about the revenue share percent. It’s about the total cost of ownership (TCO) over the life of the contract. Salesforce’s proposal may include multiple components and potential add-on fees.

You need complete clarity on what you’re paying for – and you should negotiate to bundle as much as possible into the base price.

Here’s how to ensure you’re not caught off-guard by hidden costs:

• What’s Included vs. Extra: Ask Salesforce to spell out exactly what the Commerce Cloud subscription fee covers. Does it include hosting infrastructure and bandwidth? How about support services and account management? Are features like Einstein AI, personalization, or integrations included, or are they additional? Understand every line item. If certain essentials aren’t included, negotiate to include them or at least know their costs upfront.
• Hidden Fees and Usage Caps: Look for less-obvious charges. For instance, are there fees for things like API calls, overage charges for traffic spikes, or limits on transaction volume before extra costs kick in? Salesforce Commerce Cloud is fully managed, but large spikes in traffic or orders may incur additional “extra capacity” costs. Negotiate these away or cap them. You want predictable costs, not surprise bills because your holiday traffic was double what was expected.
• Sandboxes and Environments: Enterprise retailers need multiple sandbox environments (for development, testing, etc.). Salesforce often limits the number of sandboxes in standard agreements. Ensure your contract includes a sufficient number of sandboxes at no extra charge. If the standard is, say, two, but you need five for various projects and continuous integration, push to get those included.
• Support Level: Confirm what support is provided. Basic support may be included, but premium support (such as faster response times or a dedicated representative) may incur additional costs. If you’re a large account, you should ask for top-tier support as part of the deal. 24/7 support, quick issue resolution, and a named support team can be negotiated into the contract rather than paid as an add-on.
• Third-Party Fees: Sometimes the Commerce Cloud contract might not cover services you assume it does. For example, is a Content Delivery Network (CDN) included for global content caching, or will you need to pay for Salesforce’s CDN or use your own? What about integrations with other Salesforce products – any connector or license fees? Get these details out in the open.

Checklist – Items to Verify in Your Contract:

Make sure the agreement clearly addresses each of the following cost items. If any are missing, raise them during negotiation:

• Hosting & Infrastructure: Verify that all cloud hosting, bandwidth, and storage costs are included in your subscription fee.
• Support Services: Confirm the level of support (business hours vs. 24/7, response SLAs) and whether it’s included or requires an upgrade.
• Sandbox Environments: Ensure you have enough development/test sandboxes included. Negotiate additional sandboxes if needed for free.
• Seasonal Scaling: Clarify how seasonal traffic spikes are handled – you shouldn’t pay penalties or additional fees for temporary surges in traffic or orders.
• CDN & Security: Check if CDN services, DDoS protection, and other security/performance features are part of the package or billed separately.

By clarifying the total cost of ownership and nailing down what’s in the contract, you prevent Salesforce from sneaking in extra charges later.

A Commerce Cloud deal should be holistic: the percentage fee plus all the essential “extras” required to actually run a large-scale storefront. If it’s necessary for your store’s success, get it included upfront.

Strategies for controlling cost – Managing GMV Overage Clauses: How to Cap and Control Commerce Cloud Costs.

Peak Traffic and Seasonality Clauses

Retail is often seasonal. You might do a huge percentage of your sales during the holiday peak, while experiencing low-volume periods in the off-season.

Salesforce’s standard model might not automatically account for that variability – so you need to negotiate protections for both low and high periods:

• Avoid Punitive Minimums: Many revenue-share contracts come with minimum fee commitments, sometimes calculated monthly or annually. Be wary of monthly minimum GMV or fee requirements if your sales fluctuate. For example, if you have a $500k/month minimum GMV baked in, but you only do $200k in January, you’re paying for revenue you didn’t actually earn. Negotiate for seasonal flexibility – perhaps an annualized minimum instead of strict monthly ones, or lower minimums in known slow months. The goal is to avoid paying high fees during lean months.
• Scale Up for Peaks at No Extra Cost: Peak season is when you make your money – the platform must support it without a hitch. Ensure the contract guarantees capacity for traffic spikes. Salesforce Commerce Cloud is cloud-based and should auto-scale to handle surges (like Black Friday traffic). Get a clause that says you can utilize burst capacity without incurring separate “burst fees” or needing a last-minute contract adjustment. In other words, if you suddenly have 2x traffic in November, you pay the same percentage, with no infrastructure surcharge.
• Performance SLAs for Peak Times: It’s not just about cost – it’s also about performance. Negotiate Service Level Agreements (SLAs) that hold Salesforce accountable for uptime and response time during critical peak periods. For instance, insist on 99.9% uptime during the holiday season, with penalties or credits if they fail to meet it. This gives you assurance (and recourse) that Salesforce will support your biggest sales days properly. You might also include an SLA for page load times or transaction processing speeds under peak load, if possible.
• Cap Peak Month Charges: If your revenue share fee is calculated monthly, one gigantic month could mean a huge fee. Try to negotiate a cap on any single month’s fee or an averaging method. For example, if you do an unexpected flash sale that blows up one month, you don’t want that one month’s fee to skyrocket your costs beyond budget. Some retailers ask for a clause like “any single month’s GMV fee above X will be forgiven or smoothed out over the year.” Salesforce may not readily agree, but even an annual cap (which implicitly caps the total of all months) can address this.

The takeaway is to align the contract with your business cycle. Salesforce’s standard terms might assume steady sales; most retail isn’t steady.

By building in seasonality clauses, you ensure you’re not overpaying when sales are low and not under-provisioned when sales are high.

Bundling for Discounts

If your company uses more than one Salesforce product (or plans to), you have a strong hand to play: bundle your deals.

Salesforce isn’t just Commerce Cloud; it’s Sales Cloud (CRM), Service Cloud, Marketing Cloud, etc. The more you buy, the more they’ll deal:

• Bundle Commerce + Marketing Cloud (or Others): Perhaps you’re also considering Salesforce Marketing Cloud for email/marketing automation, or you already use Salesforce CRM. When negotiating Commerce Cloud, bring those into the conversation. Salesforce may offer a better rate on Commerce Cloud if it means winning or retaining your Marketing Cloud business at the same time. They want a bigger share of your software wallet, and you can use that to your advantage. For example, let them know that a concession on Commerce Cloud could secure a multi-cloud, multi-year commitment from your company.
• Cross-Product Concessions: Even if the products are sold by different teams within Salesforce, at the end of the day, it’s one company’s revenue. You can negotiate things like credits or discounts on one cloud if you invest in another. Maybe you agree to a longer term or larger scope on Marketing Cloud, and in return, Salesforce drops the Commerce Cloud percentage a bit or waives an add-on fee. This package deal approach can unlock discounts that wouldn’t be possible if you negotiated each contract in isolation.
• Total Salesforce Spend Leverage: Make sure Salesforce’s account reps know your total annual spend (or potential spend) across all Salesforce products. A Commerce Cloud deal worth $500k/year on its own might not get the royal treatment. But if Salesforce realizes you’re actually a $2M/year account when adding CRM, Marketing Cloud, etc., they’ll be more flexible. Use that as leverage to say, “We’re investing heavily in the Salesforce ecosystem – we expect a preferred pricing in return across the board.” This can mean securing volume discounts or more favorable terms that reflect your importance as a customer.
• Co-term and Co-termination: Align contract end dates and renewal discussions for multiple Salesforce products if you can. This gives you even more leverage at renewal time, because Salesforce will be keen to prevent a big chunk of their business with you from all coming up for grabs at once. If you bundle now, also consider having them coterminous (same end date), so that in 3 years, for example, you can negotiate everything together again (or consider alternatives with a holistic view).

In essence, think bigger picture. Don’t negotiate Commerce Cloud in a silo if you have other Salesforce products.

A bundled negotiation might be more complex internally, but from Salesforce’s perspective, a win in one area can justify giving ground in another.

Leverage that to maximize discounts and favorable terms on Commerce Cloud as part of a broader partnership.

Contract Negotiation Strategies

Beyond specific price points and features, there are strategic approaches you should use when hammering out the contract terms.

These strategies protect you from runaway costs and ensure you have flexibility throughout the relationship:

• Explore Different Pricing Models: Salesforce might default to GMV-based pricing, but ask if they can offer alternatives, such as an order-based model or a hybrid. For example, an order-based model could be a fixed fee per transaction/order, which sometimes benefits retailers with higher average order values. Always request both options in writing. This not only lets you compare which is cheaper for your business model, but also signals to Salesforce that you’re looking for the best value. They may sharpen the deal when they know you’re evaluating structure, not just rate. A hybrid model (lower % of GMV plus a small per-order fee, or a fixed annual fee plus a % cap) might also be on the table if you negotiate creatively.
• Cap Your Costs: Try to negotiate a ceiling on annual fees. This is essentially a safety net – no matter how much your sales grow or what unforeseen spikes occur, you won’t pay above a certain amount in a year. For instance, if you project $50M in sales, you might cap fees as if you did $60M (giving some cushion). If you blow past $60M, the rest of the year’s fees are effectively free. Salesforce will resist an outright cap, but they might agree to mechanisms like a tiered reduction that mathematically caps it, or a clause to revisit terms if GMV goes, say, 50% over forecast. The point is to avoid infinite upside to what you pay. You deserve cost predictability beyond a point.
• Guard Against Renewal Surprises: Salesforce contracts often have tricky renewal clauses. They might lock you into an automatic uplift (e.g., +7% fee increase) in the next term or require renegotiation where they have the leverage of you being deeply integrated. Negotiate renewal terms now. Push for a cap on any renewal rate increase (for example, “no more than 3% increase year-over-year” or even flat renewal at the same rate). Alternatively, include a one-time renewal discount or an agreement that renewal pricing will be based on the same tier you originally negotiated. The goal is to prevent the scenario where you come to renew and Salesforce tries to jump your fee from, say, 2% to 2.5% because you’re entrenched. Also, consider adding a clause that you can exit or renegotiate if certain performance metrics aren’t met – it gives you an out or leverage at renewal.
• Contract Length and Flexibility: Decide on the term (length) strategically. A longer contract (3-5 years) can often secure a better rate now, but locks you in. If you go long, build in flexibility clauses – e.g., the ability to re-rate (adjust pricing) if your business changes significantly, or an option to terminate early for cause or with notice (even if with a penalty, as a last resort). If you prefer a shorter term (1-2 years to keep options open), you might pay a bit more percentage now, but retain leverage sooner. Whichever you choose, ensure mid-term check-ins are part of the deal if possible, especially if growth or market conditions deviate from assumptions.

To summarize these strategies, here’s a quick look at key negotiation levers, what they do for you, and how Salesforce might react:

Using these levers in combination will give you a much stronger contract.

You’ll have locked-in advantages for yourself and minimize the risks of Salesforce’s model. Remember, anything not negotiated will favor Salesforce – so address these points before you sign.

FAQs

Q: Can contract cap Salesforce’s Commerce Cloud fees?
A: Yes, you can negotiate a cap on fees, but it must be explicitly written into the contract. For example, you might agree that you’ll pay 2% of revenue up to a maximum of $X in fees per year. If structured right, that acts as a financial guardrail. Salesforce may not offer this, but many customers have successfully negotiated a cap or at least a sliding scale that effectively limits the maximum cost. It provides peace of mind that a blockbuster sales year won’t blow your budget on fees.

Q: Are competitor benchmarks effective in a Salesforce negotiation?
A: Absolutely. Bringing competitor pricing data (like Shopify Plus, BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce, etc.) to the table is one of the most effective ways to get Salesforce to budge on price. It shows you’re an informed buyer with alternatives. Salesforce reps often position their solution as premium, but they also know they need to stay in the ballpark on cost. By citing specific numbers – e.g., “Shopify Plus would cost us roughly half of this” – you create pressure for Salesforce to close that gap or risk losing a deal. Even if you have no immediate plan to switch, the threat that you could go elsewhere gives you leverage throughout the negotiation.

Q: Can we renegotiate mid-term if our GMV grows faster than expected?
A: It’s tricky. Generally, once you sign, you’re locked into the agreed terms for the contract duration (commonly 3 years). If your sales wildly exceed projections, you’ll be paying proportionally more – which is great for Salesforce. They have little incentive to renegotiate downward mid-term. However, you might build in a clause to revisit pricing if GMV exceeds a certain threshold by a wide margin. In practice, if you grow exceptionally and become unhappy with the fees, you could approach Salesforce to discuss an early renewal or extension with better rates (in exchange for a longer commitment). Salesforce might entertain that to secure you for extra years, but they won’t refund what you’ve paid. The best approach is to negotiate those possibilities upfront (e.g., tiered pricing that already accounts for growth, or a cap as discussed). Mid-term changes are not guaranteed unless contractually allowed.

Q: Is a hybrid pricing model (GMV% + per-order fee) possible with Commerce Cloud?
A: It’s not standard, but it can be negotiated in some cases. Salesforce historically prefers the straightforward GMV percentage. Yet, for very large deals or unique situations, they have shown flexibility. A hybrid model might look like: a lower percentage on GMV plus a small fixed fee per order, or a base subscription fee plus a reduced revenue share. The idea is to balance costs for different business models (for instance, if you have a few high-value orders versus many low-value orders). To get this, you’ll likely need to make the case that the standard model overcharges you and that an alternative structure would be more equitable. It would be helpful if you could demonstrate what your costs would look like under different models. Don’t expect Salesforce to offer it outright, but if you ask and have logical reasoning (and a competitive quote to back it up), they may come to the table with creative options.

Q: What extras should always be included in the total cost (TCO)?
A: At a minimum, ensure the contract covers all the fundamental components to run your site without surprise add-ons later. This includes cloud hosting and environment costs, a reasonable number of sandbox environments for development/testing, basic support services (and ideally premium support if you’re a large customer), and any essential infrastructure like a CDN for content delivery and security features. Also, if you’re buying multiple Salesforce products as part of your solution (like integrating with Marketing Cloud or Order Management), check if connectors or API usage for those are included. Essentially, your TCO should encompass the platform license (revenue share or however structured) plus all necessary tech and support to use that license fully. If anything is listed as “optional” but you know you’ll need it (e.g., additional storage, an AI add-on, etc.), negotiate it into the base price. Don’t assume anything is included—get it in writing.

Five Expert Recommendations

Finally, to wrap up, here are five expert tips to remember when negotiating your Salesforce Commerce Cloud deal.

These are battle-tested strategies from seasoned e-commerce negotiators to help you secure the best terms:

1. Anchor with Competitive Benchmarks: Start your pricing talks by referencing market alternatives. It sets a reasonable anchor point and forces Salesforce to justify its cost. If you can say “Competitor X would cost us roughly $Y less,” you frame the negotiation around how much more value Salesforce must provide or how much they need to come down. Never reveal your budget first – reveal the competition’s pricing.
2. Demand Tiered & Scalable Pricing: Don’t accept a flat percentage that stays the same whether you sell $10M or $1B. Insist on tiered pricing that rewards your growth. If you plan to grow, Salesforce should grow with you, not just profit from you. Tiered breaks (and even the possibility of lowering the rate in renewals as you hit new levels) ensure you’re not penalized for success. It also protects you if growth is slower – negotiate those lower tiers or rate reductions in case things don’t take off as fast.
3. Push for Fee Caps on Peaks: Make sure there’s a safety net for peak scenarios. Whether it’s a cap on any given month’s fees or an annual cap, put a lid on how high the costs can go. This is crucial for budgeting and for reporting to your CFO that there’s no blank check scenario. You might phrase it as “we need cost certainty that in a best-case sales scenario, we’re not paying more than X.” It’s easier to negotiate this before signing than to beg for relief later.
4. Bundle and Leverage Multi-Cloud Investments: If your company uses Salesforce CRM, Marketing Cloud, Service Cloud, or any other products, bring that to the forefront. Use the total relationship as leverage. Salesforce values long-term, high-value customers – if they see you as a big-picture account, they will be more inclined to accommodate on Commerce Cloud pricing. Don’t be shy to say, “We’re evaluating our entire Salesforce spend.” This often opens the door to enterprise-level discounts or special terms that a standalone Commerce Cloud deal wouldn’t get.
5. Scrutinize and Question Every Line Item: Before signing, review every detail in the contract. If you see anything you don’t understand or that seems extraneous, ask about it and negotiate it. Common areas to double-check are clauses on minimum commitments, overage fees, what’s included (support hours, upgrades, new features), and any usage limits. Have your procurement or legal team comb through for vague language. If Salesforce says “that’s just standard,” remember standard terms typically favor the vendor. You have the right to question and change them. It’s far better to take extra time negotiating now than to live with a bad term for years.

By following these recommendations, you’ll approach your Commerce Cloud deal with a clear strategy and a protective mindset.

Salesforce is a powerful platform and can be a great partner for growth – but only if you secure a contract that aligns with your success, not just theirs. Negotiation is your opportunity to shape that partnership on your terms. Good luck, and happy negotiating!

Read about our Salesforce Negotiation Services

Do you want to know more about our Salesforce Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit